The short answer to the question is yes and no. It's not as simple as specialists vs. generalists in the wildlife economy sector, which is transdisciplinary and requires those who can see the bigger picture, as well as experts in particular fields, to be truly effective. 

Specialisation refers to narrowing one's focus to the development of a very particular set of skills, which makes working in a diverse team critical, because it is the interconnectedness and communication amongst team members with different expertise that leads to success. However, specialists and generalists are not mutually exclusive.

Is it better to specialise or cultivate a broad knowledge base to work in the wildlife economy?

If wildlife economies (and that means the success of biodiversity and people) are to go hand in hand, then specialisation may not always be the way forward. It may actually be better, especially in early career or as a student in training, to acquaint oneself with all parts of the whole. Then, when one becomes a team member and begins to specialise, they are already equipped with knowledge of what the other parts of the whole entail and how they fit together.

To put this into context, there is no point in a protected area manager designing their park based on a biodiversity hotspot if they have no understanding of the resources that the community uses from that hotspot. They may use these resources to sustain not only their community but also their culture, beliefs, and traditions. The protected area manager also needs to understand the community's population growth, where its main sources of income lie, and what potential alternative income-generating activities are available.

A sustainable wildlife economy benefits people and nature, using habitats and wildlife in an ecological, economic and socially sustainable way. When communities living closest to wildlife have a clear role and stake in managing nature, they have a stronger incentive to conserve it.

Joyce Msuya, Assistant Secretary-General of the United Nations and Deputy Executive Director of the UN Environment Programme
(See: Wildlife economies: What are they and how do they impact conservation?)

In another example, the designer of wildlife tracking collars and chips will not design a functioning piece of equipment if he or she is not familiar with the biology and ethology of the wildlife itself – how they move, interact, hunt, or even what would make them easier prey.

Elephant

Wild elephant. Photography by Will Shirley via Unplash.

It was very common in the 1800s for 14-year-olds to attend university for a decade before leaving with several degrees under their belts; most were in theology, but they also included mathematics, law, engineering, and medicine. These graduates were true polymaths – individuals whose knowledge spans a substantial number of subjects and is known to draw on complex bodies of knowledge to solve specific problems.

Across Africa, we are finding many students graduating from their training institutions or colleges with either a very broad, non-practical set of theoretical knowledge or a highly specialised focus in a specific area, yet are unable to fully integrate into a team. Because they lack a broad understanding of the aspects involved in a successful wildlife economy, we end up with policy-level gaps that do not reflect what is happening on the ground. Both are problematic in setting up a successful interdisciplinary team capable of the complex problem-solving needed to tackle diverse conservation issues.

If we are to succeed in the sustainable utilisation of nature, to reach an equilibrium of economic, ecological, and social interconnectedness between people and nature, then we need leaders who are more like polymaths – interdisciplinary leaders who can take the broad-scale picture and delegate the finer tasks to those who have specialised knowledge.

We cannot continue to have government officials and policy creators who have never seen the piece of land they are being asked to rule on, anti-hunting activists who have never seen the utter decimation of wildlife from the land because of no economic gain. We cannot stay in our ivory towers of specialisation and think we are making a change if we are not networking with broad-scale thinkers, those who have the whole picture at their fingertips.

For a country to claim a successful wildlife economy, an interconnectedness between science and policy, between wildlife laws and the social and ecological state on the ground is required. To get to this point, it needs training and education systems that equip young people with the skills and knowledge they need. Go ahead, study broad systems and subjects such as geography and ecology alongside psychology and engineering because, as the UNDP Administrator, Achim Steiner, said, ‘If 90% of conservation work is with people, what then changes people?’

Ms Hollie Mgog

AWEI Fellow: Ms Hollie M'gog, Kenya

There is one more thing that students need to emerge from training with: the always-present knowledge that we don’t know what we don’t know – that there is always more to learn and more links to make.

I am honoured to come on board as a Training Fellow with AWEI. I hope that my work as a Fellow in mentoring upcoming students, and my work with ShareScreen Africa, which aims to make conservation training material by connecting guest speakers and training institutions, as well as my work to build practical land skills in fellow Africans, will make a difference and will give more students a knowledge base that will span ‘a substantial number of subjects’ so that they can ‘draw on complex bodies of knowledge to solve the specific issue of balancing biodiversity off-take and conservation.’