Foraging of wild plants to sustain human values and value chains
Foraging is the act of gathering wild resources, often food, that many humans engage in, either occasionally or as a regular activity, and so foraging of wild plants is more common than we think. Have you ever picked a fruit or a flower growing spontaneously along a stream, field, or footpath? How did you feel picking a wild plant? Would you consider yourself a forager? If you have picked something, you should, by definition.
There is growing interest in the phenomenon of foraging, so I recently published a global review examining who forages, where, why, and how. I found examples of twenty populations of Indigenous Peoples that lead mainly forager-hunter lifestyles on five continents, and many more examples of people who forage in rural and urban areas from time to time. These examples include, but are not limited to, agropastoralists who forage for materials while their animals graze, farmers who complement their agricultural production with wild materials gathered from their farms and forests, and rural and urban people who forage in the gardens, fields, and other green spaces around them.
Foraging motives and benefits
People who forage almost always tend to associate the activity with a positive sense of connection to nature. Long-time foragers consider the knowledge, beliefs, and practices around foraging a part of their sociocultural identity and spirituality. Their foraging principles are based on an intimate understanding of the workings of the natural landscape, and they consider their gathering activities an act of care for it. More recent foragers turn to foraging as a means of reconnecting with their childhood memories, or with another time and place in their lives, spent in nature.
Increasingly, people are taking up foraging as a social and recreational pursuit, learning from experienced foragers, guidebooks and apps, and with regular club meetups. This trend has seen an uptick since the pandemic, when the societal need to interact with people and nature increased significantly. This led me to explore and establish another global theme: foraging and interacting with biodiversity, be it in wild forests, cultivated farms, or urban gardens, has distinct benefits for human health and wellbeing.
My studies found that these benefits manifest in the following ways: Foragers tend to procure and eat diverse foods from diverse sources, increasing their exposure to different microbes and different micronutrients, and improving their physical health. People who forage develop knowledge of and a relationship with the places where they forage and the species that they forage. This, in turn, fosters a sense of belonging and stewardship towards these spaces and species, improving people’s mental wellbeing.
in the coastal belt of KwaZulu-Natal and the savanna of Gauteng and North West Province
When people value and care for a variety of species in their surroundings, they gradually perpetuate a system that supports biodiversity through positive feedback, improving ecosystem health. Seeing as foraging can have such positive human and ecological outcomes, would we not want more people to forage? I posed this question to land managers in some urban municipalities in eastern South Africa. What emerged was a careful consideration of where urban foraging would benefit people and nature (verges, parks, gardens), and where it would likely be detrimental (urban natural areas). The concern around overexploitation resonates with the wider dialectic on nature conservation.
The wildlife economy
In addition to health and wellbeing benefits, foraging also enables some people to save and earn money. Wild food and materials growing in accessible areas can be obtained free of charge, helping people reduce spending. Several people worldwide also sell the materials they forage, either in raw form or by processing them into specialised products. This trade in foraged materials can make a significant contribution to household and national economies and is being recognised by governments as the wildlife economy or, alternatively, the biodiversity economy.
Some ecologists and conservationists continue to caution against the wildlife economy model, concerned that it may deplete species, disturb ecosystems, and deepen socioeconomic inequality. Others argue that it can create economic incentives to conserve species, protect their ecosystems, and link them to sustainable livelihoods. Governments around the world are attempting to reconcile these divergent perspectives to develop a pragmatic approach to both conserve and use natural resources through the wildlife economy. For example, the Southern African Development Community (SADC) is promoting a Wildlife-Based Economy Strategy Framework. Foraging is a prime example of a wildlife-based economic activity - but which policy action helps or hinders it?
Foraging and policy in South Africa
I use South Africa as a case study, given that it is a pioneer in the wildlife economy, and the source of much research (including mine) on the foraging of wild resources. South Africa’s National Biodiversity Economy Strategy (SANBES) is currently being updated to more comprehensively include, among other things, the foraging or harvesting of wild plant resources, which it terms "harvesting". As part of this update, the Strategy commits to developing a structured and formal ‘Bioprospecting, Biotrade, and Biodiversity-based Harvesting and Production Sector’. With institutional support, this sector will grow over ten years (2026-2036), contributing tenfold to the national GDP relative to its 2020 contribution (ZAR 1.85 billion, equivalent to USD 110 million).
The strategy also notes that the present biodiversity (wildlife) economy is dominated by informal trade within the country and by the export of raw, foraged wildlife materials to production companies abroad. It plans to transform this economy by institutionalising indigenous knowledge (through researcher-practitioner collaboration); developing product value-addition capacities (for processed pharmaceuticals, foods, and cosmetics) within the country; and formalising local markets for wildlife products such as indigenous foods, medicines, and plants.
How communities and culture can sustain the wildlife economy
The SANBES focuses on cultivating species of interest for agriculture, apiculture, horticulture, game hunting, and related sectors. The proposed development of value chains is linked to organised production systems rather than natural ecosystems, thereby effectively reducing the risk of overharvesting or overhunting, which is often a conservation concern. The Strategy takes a ‘mainstreaming’ approach to enclosing biodiversity and wildlife ‘resources’ within controlled systems to ensure continuous production. In doing so, it risks replicating the inequalities and contradictions of agro-industry, which is well-recognised as one of the biggest threats to the planet.
The SANBES does not explicitly consider wildlife that can only be collected from natural ecosystems. Species that cannot (yet) be cultivated, such as various wild fruits and mopane worms, will continue to be foraged in natural habitats. There is a need to enable sustainable enterprise embedded in these habitats, which calls for more research and regulation on sustainable practices that integrate indigenous knowledge and business standards. Industry’s investment in converting cultural processes into marketable products may alienate people from the often deeply personal activity of foraging. What the SANBES plans to ‘transform’ into formal jobs, foragers regard as flexible and sovereign livelihoods. The commercialisation of foraged products will have to be guided by principles of community-driven enterprise.
The Strategy’s proposal to create community-owned conservation areas where ‘audited conservation’ activities, including foraging, are encouraged holds promise. My work with foragers and land managers in some South African cities found that both parties agreed that designated foraging areas are a great idea. Such areas would have clear boundaries and rules around who can forage (locals), for how much (person and season quotas), and when (not during crucial reproductive seasons). The collateral benefit is that ‘wild’ natural habitat supporting foraged species is conserved and made accessible to people for sustainable use. The communication of sustainable practices and their collective adherence will be a key determinant of the success of such initiatives.
-
Mallika Sardeshpande